Menu text large

Story Hill Menu

Milwaukee locations: Juneau Avenue | Story Hill | North Avenue

Call it in: (414) 727-9200

Order Online
or choose a different location.

Pizzas

Section titled Pizzas

Whole pies are available in: 12" (serves 1-2) | 16" (serves 2-4) | 20" (serves 4-6)

6 artisan pizzas on counter

Signature Pizzas

Section titled Signature Pizzas
  • Mac n’ Cheese Pizza

    Mac n’ Cheese Vegetarian iconV

    Ian’s all-time best seller! Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Mac Noodles, & Cheddar

    $13.50 | $18 | $22.50

  • Maui-Wowie

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Ham, Pineapple, & House-pickled Jalapeños

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Baked Penne Vegetarian iconV

    Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella, Cacciatore Tomatoes, Penne Noodles, Cheddar, Feta, & Parmesan

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Penne Marinara Vegetarian iconV

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Penne Noodles, Crème, & Asiago

    $13.50 | $18 | $22.50

  • Spinach Feta Pesto Pizza

    Spinach Feta Pesto Vegetarian iconV

    House-Made Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella, Sautéed Greens, & Feta

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Tomato Pesto Pizza

    Tomato Pesto Vegetarian iconV

    House-Made Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella, & Sliced Tomato

    $15 | $20 | $25

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Buffalo Chicken

    Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Buffalo Chicken, & Bleu Cheese

    $16.50 | $22 | $27.50

  • Buffalo Cauliflower Vegetarian iconV

    Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Buffalo Cauliflower, & Bleu Cheese

    $16.50 | $22 | $27.50

  • Pomodoro Vegetarian iconV

    Cacciatore Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Sautéed Greens, & Feta

    $16.50 | $22 | $27.50

  • Cheesy Potato & Ranch Vegetarian iconV

    Mozzarella, Butter, Asiago, Cheddar, Diced Potato, & Ranch

    $16.50 | $22 | $27.50

  • BBQ Chicken Pineapple

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, BBQ Chicken, & Pineapple

    $15 | $20 | $25

  • Penne Alfredo Vegetarian iconV

    Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella, Penne Noodles, Asiago, & Choice of Chicken, House-made Sausage, Ham**, or Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Drunken Ravioli Pizza

    Drunken Ravioli Vegetarian iconV

    Vodka Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Cheese Ravioli, Butter, & Asiago

    $16.50 | $22 | $27.50

  • All The Veg Pizza

    All The Veg Vegetarian iconV

    Cacciatore Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Onions, Bell Peppers, Artichokes, & Black Olives

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Macadilla Killa

    Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Spicy Chicken, Mac n’ Cheese, & Tortilla Top

    $24 | $32 | $40

  • Quesadilla

    Chipotle Crème Sauce, Pepper Jack, Choice of Spicy Chicken, House-made Chorizo or Corn and Bean Medley, Cheddar, Pico de Gallo, & a Tortilla Top

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Four Cheese Vegetarian iconV

    Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Asiago, Gruyère, & Parmesan

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Smokey the Bandit Pizza

    Smokey the Bandit

    BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella, BBQ Chicken, Cheddar, Bacon, & Ranch

    $19.50 | $26 | $32.50

  • Veggie Bandit Vegetarian iconV

    BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella, Diced Potato, Cheddar, & Ranch

    $15 | $20 | $25

  • Chicken Cordon Bleu

    Crème Sauce, Mozzarella, Ham**, Chicken, & Bleu Cheese

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Macho Nacho

    Chipotle Crème Sauce, Pepper Jack, House-made Chorizo, Cheddar, Tortilla Strips, Pico de Gallo, & Salsa Verde

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Mushroom Pesto Bleus Vegetarian iconV

    House-Made Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella, Sautéed Greens, Sautéed Button Mushrooms, & Bleu Cheese

    $21 | $28 | $35

Classic Pizzas

Section titled Classic Pizzas
  • Classic Cheese Pizza

    Classic Cheese Vegetarian iconV

    Marinara Sauce & Extra Mozzarella

    $12 | $16.50 | $20

  • Slice of pizza on plate

    Classic Pepperoni

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, & Pepperoni

    $12 | $16.50 | $20

  • Classic Sausage

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, & House-made Sausage

    $13.50 | $18 | $22.50

  • Pepperoni & Sausage

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, & House-made Sausage

    $15 | $20 | $25

  • Pepperoni & Mushroom

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, & Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $13.50 | $18 | $22.50

  • Sausage & Mushroom

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, House-made Sausage, & Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $15 | $20 | $25

  • The Shmo

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, House-made Sausage, Sautéed Button Mushrooms, & Grilled Onions

    $16 | $21.50 | $27.50

Vegan Pizzas

Section titled Vegan Pizzas

Ian’s carefully crafts their vegan pizzas, using the finest vegan ingredients the local community has to offer.

  • Vegan Mac n’ Cheese Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Crème Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Mac Noodles, & Good Planet® Cheddar

    $19.50 | $26 | $32.50

  • Vegan Philly Cheese Steak Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Crème Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Bell Peppers, Onion, House-made Walnut Sausage, & House-made Vegan Ranch

    $22.50 | $30 | $37.50

  • Vegan Macadilla Killa Vegan iconVG

    Vegan Crème Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Spicy Roasted Cauliflower, Macaroni, Good Planet® Cheddar, & Tortilla Top

    $24 | $32 | $40

  • Vegan Veggie Bandit Vegan iconVG

    BBQ Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, BBQ Potato, House-made Vegan Ranch, & Good Planet® Cheddar

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Vegan Cheesy Potato & Ranch Vegan iconVG

    Good Planet® Mozzarella, Diced Potato, Good Planet® Cheddar, & House-made Vegan Ranch

    $22.50 | $30 | $37.50

  • Vegan Pepperoni Mushroom Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, House-made Vegan Pepperoni, & Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $19.50 | $26 | $32.50

  • Vegan Penne Alfredo Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Alfredo Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Penne Noodles, & Choice of Roasted Cauliflower or House-Made Walnut Sausage

    $22.50 | $30 | $37.50

  • Vegan Roasted Cauliflower Pesto Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Pesto Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, & Roasted Cauliflower

    $19.50 | $26 | $32.50

  • Vegan Gyro Vegan iconVG

    Garlic Oil, Good Planet® Mozzarella, House-made Walnut Sausage, House-made Vegan Tzatziki Sauce, Sliced Tomato, & Onion

    $24 | $32 | $40

  • Vegan Smokey the Bandit Vegan iconVG

    BBQ Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Roasted Cauliflower, House-made Vegan Ranch, & Good Planet® Cheddar

    $22.50 | $30 | $37.50

  • Vegan BBQ Cauliflower Pineapple Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Roasted Cauliflower, BBQ Sauce, & Pineapple

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Vegan Taco Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Choice of Spicy Roasted Cauliflower or Vegan Chorizo, Pico de Gallo, Good Planet® Cheddar, & House-made Vegan Ranch

    $24 | $32 | $40

  • Vegan Penne Pesto Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Pesto Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, & Penne Noodles

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Vegan Tomato Pesto Vegan iconVG

    House-made Vegan Pesto Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, & Sliced Tomato

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Vegan All The Veg Vegan iconVG

    Cacciatore Tomatoes, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Onions, Bell Peppers, Artichokes, & Black Olives

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Vegan Macho Nacho Vegan iconVG

    House-made Chipotle Crème Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Vegan Chorizo, Cheddar, Tortilla Strips, Pico de Gallo, & Salsa Verde

    $25.50 | $34 | $42.50

  • Vegan Hurley Vegan iconVG

    (Fall Out Boy Drummer, Andy Hurley, Signature Vegan Pizza) Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Vegan Sausage, Vegan Pepperoni, & Good Planet® Cheddar.

    $25.50 | $34 | $42.50

  • Vegan Shmo Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, Grilled Onions, Button Mushrooms, & House-made Walnut Sausage

    $21 | $28 | $35

  • Vegan Sausage Mushroom Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, House-made Walnut Sausage, & Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $19.50 | $27 | $32.50

  • Vegan Sausage Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, House-made Walnut Sausage

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Vegan Pepperoni Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, & House-made Vegan Pepperoni

    $18 | $24 | $30

  • Vegan Cheese Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce & Good Planet® Mozzarella

    $13.50 | $18| $22.50

  • Vegan Mushroom Vegan iconVG

    Marinara Sauce, Good Planet® Mozzarella, & Sautéed Button Mushrooms

    $18 | $24 | $30

Build Your Own Pizza

Section titled Build Your Own Pizza

12" | 16" | 20"

Starting Price:

$10.50 | $14 | $17.50

Includes 1 basic sauce and Mozzarella

Toppings:

Basic | *Premium | **Super Premium

Cheeses

Shredded Mozzarella, Asiago, Bleu*, Cheddar, Feta, Gruyère, Pepper Jack, Parmesan

Sauces

Marinara, Alfredo*, BBQ, Crème Fraîche, Hot Sauce, House-made Pesto**, Vodka Marinara*, Ranch, Chipotle Crème*

Meats

All-natural Pepperoni, House-made Berkshire Pork Sausage*, Ham**, Bacon*, Grilled Chicken*, Spicy Chicken*, BBQ Chicken*, House-made Chorizo*

Veggies

Artichokes*, House-pickled Jalapeños, Sautéed Button Mushrooms, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives, Raw Onions, Grilled Onions, Bell Peppers, Pineapple, Pico de Gallo, Diced Potato, Sautéed Greens*, Cacciatore Tomatoes, Sliced or Diced Tomato, Banana Peppers, Corn and Bean Medley

Noodles

Macaroni, Penne, Cheese Ravioli*

Vegan Toppings

Good Planet® Mozzarella**, Good Planet® Cheddar*, House-made Vegan Pesto**, House-made Vegan Ranch*, House-made Vegan Crème*, House-made Vegan Chipotle Crème*, House-made Vegan Tzatziki*, BBQ, Marinara, Vegan Chorizo**, House-made Vegan Pepperoni**, House-made Walnut Sausage**, Roasted Cauliflower (Spicy, BBQ, Grilled)*

Other

Tortilla Chips, Tortilla Quesadilla Top, Salsa Verde*, Schroeter's 12" Gluten-Free Crust**

Salad Veggies

Salads

Section titled Salads

Ian’s Signature Salads are healthy and delicious with locally sourced, whole-food ingredients.


Signature Salads

Section titled Signature Salads

Sizes: Side | Entrée | Party | Tub

  • Southwest Salad Vegetarian iconV Gluten-Friendly Icon GF

    Romaine, Corn and Bean Medley, Tortilla Strips, Pepper Jack, & Green Chile Ranch Dressing

    $3.75 | $7 | $29 | $50

  • Caesar Salad

    Romaine, Hard-boiled Eggs, Parmesan, House-made Croutons, & Caesar Dressing

    $3.75 | $7 | $29 | $50

  • The Wisco Salad Gluten-Friendly Icon GF

    Mixed Greens, Maple-cayenne Pecans, Dried Cranberries, Green Apples, Bacon, Bleu Cheese, & Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette

    $5.25 | $9 | $35 | $60

  • Greek Salad Vegetarian iconV Gluten-Friendly Icon GF

    Romaine, Artichokes, Feta, Olive Medley, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers, & White Balsamic and Herb Vinaigrette

    $4.75 | $8 | $32 | $55

  • Ian’s House Salad Vegetarian iconV Gluten-Friendly Icon GF

    Romaine, Roasted Grape Tomatoes, Cucumber, Carrots, Cheddar, House-made Croutons, & Ranch Dressing

    $4.25 | $7 | $29 | $50

Build Your Own Salad

Section titled Build Your Own Salad

$2.50 | $3.50 | $18.50 | $32.50

Includes choice of greens, and choice of dressing

Greens

Mixed Greens, Baby Spinach, or Romaine.

Mix-ins:

Basic | *Premium | **Super Premium

Veggies & Fruits

Apples*, Artichokes*, Asparagus*, Bell Pepper Mix, Button Mushrooms, Brussels Sprouts*, Black Olives, Carrots, Dried Cranberries, Corn and Bean Medley*, Cucumbers, Kalamata Olives*, Red Onions, Roasted Grape Tomatoes*, Seasonal Mix-ins

Cheeses

Asiago*, Cheddar*, Feta*, Bleu Cheese*, Shredded Mozzarella*, Shaved Parmesan*, Pepper Jack*

Proteins

Bacon**, Grilled Chicken**, Hard Boiled Egg*, Spicy Pecans**

Dressings

Green Chile Ranch, Caesar, Ian’s Famous Ranch, Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette, White Balsamic and Herb Vinaigrette, Vegan Creamy Lemon Herb, Seasonal Dressings

Other

House-made Croutons, Tortilla Strips

Dressing bottle and salad illustration

Slices

Section titled Slices

Swing by and grab a slice.

Cheese or Pepperoni

$4

Specialty Slice

$5

Vegan Slice

$6

Hand holding slice of mac and cheese pizza on paper plate

Side Sticks

Section titled Side Sticks

Dunk a chewy, parmesan and herb side-stick in your choice of Ian’s house-made dipping sauces.


1

1-Pack

Sauceless

$1.25

3

3-Pack

1 Sauce

$3.50

6

6-Pack

2 Sauces

$6.50

24

24-Pack

8 Sauces

$20

Puppy Chow

Section titled Puppy Chow

Get your sweet fix with a baggie of Gluten-Friendly Puppy Chow or Vegan and Gluten-Friendly cinnamon Churro Chow.


Puppy Chow Gluten-Friendly iconGF

$3

Churro Chow Vegan iconVGGluten-Friendly iconGF

$3

Drinks

Section titled Drinks

Ian’s Pizza has a bunch of beverages. Refresh yourself with a classic or local favorite, availability may vary.

Fizzy Bubbles Illustration

Gatorade

Red, Blue

$2.50

Soda: Cans | Liters

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Cherry Coke

$1.50 | $4

Sprechers Bottles

Cream Soda, Root Beer

$3

San Pellegrino

Blood Orange, Limonata

$2

Boxed Water

$2

Dough

Section titled Dough

Bake your own NY style pizza at home with an Ian’s dough ball.

12" | 16" | 20" Dough Ball

$3 | $4 | $5

Sides

Section titled Sides

Ranch, BBQ Sauce, Marinara Sauce, Hot Sauce, Parmesan, Red Pepper Flakes • Side-Stick Sauces: Zesty Marinara, Green Chile Ranch, Bacon Queso, Garlic Butter, Vodka Marinara, Ian’s Famous Ranch

Sides

75¢ Each


Featured Seasonal Pizza

CURRENT MONTH

  • PIzza name
  • Another pizza

Coming soon

Email me whan this one is available.

  • PIzza name
  • Another pizza